Advertiser Disclosure We strive for editorial intergrity. We recieve compensation from some of the links, products and or services mentioned in this post. Read more here.

Motley Fool Rule Breakers vs Stock Advisor – What’s the Best Stock Picking Services for 2021?

Motley Fool Rule Breakers vs Stock Advisor

Rule Breakers and Stock Advisor are two great stock picking services, we’ll compare the two and guide you through the process of deciding which one is right for you.

Both Rule Breakers and Stock Advisor picks have out-performed the market by a wide margin and can make finding multi-bagger stocks much easier, however Both services have different investing philosophies so which one is right for you will depend on what your investing goals are.

Let’s jump right into the comparison of the two investing services.


Motley Fool Rule Breakers Overview:

Rule Breakers is run by David Gardner and only features his picks while Stock Advisor features both Tom and Davids Picks. Rule Breakers seeks to discover disruptive, high-growth companies with strong management teams typically under-appreciated by the mainstream.

Click Here to See the Latest Rule Breaker Picks (May 15, 2021)

Attention: Don’t miss David Gardners next Rule Breakers picks on May 13th and 27th. New members can get the service for $99/year which is 67% off the regular price. Try Rule Breakers Risk Free for 30 days.


Rule Breakers Performance vs. S&P 500

  • Rule Breakers: +293.4%
  • S&P 500: +107.3%

Rule Breakers Stock Picks

Rule Breakers members who invested $500 in each of these 5 stock picks on recommendation date are sitting on $167,122 today, or $668,488 for those that invested $2000.

Motley Fool Rule Breakers PicksReturnReturn on $500 Investment
Tesla (TSLA)9,278%$46,391
MercadoLibre (MELI)9,119%$45,596
Intuitive Surgical (ISRG)5,414%$27,068
Shopify (SHOP)5,057%$25,283
NetEase (NTES)4,557%$22,785

Those are phenomenal returns but they are also the best performing picks. So, how does an average pick perform? Let’s examine that by looking the performance of all the Q4 stock picks back to 2016.

Click Here to Try Rule Breakers Risk Free for 30 Days (May 15, 2021)

Rule Breakers Stock Picks Over the Years

David Gardner recommends investors hold his picks for 3-5 years, so let’s examine how his picks have performed over that recommended timeline.

Q4 2019 – Motley Fool Rule Breakers Picks

The Q4 2019 Rule Breakers picks beat the market by 3.9X with an average return of 157% compared to 41% for the S&P500.

Rule Breakers Picks (Q4 2019)Rate of ReturnReturn on $500 Investment
Freshpet (FRPT)184.8%$924
Insulet (PODD)22.4%$112
Peloton Interactive (PTON)177.8%$889
Etsy (ETSY)280.8%$1404
Datadog (DDOG)136.4%$682
Novocure (NVCR)138.2%$691

Q4 2018 – Motley Fool Rule Breakers Picks

The Q4 2018 Rule Breakers picks beat the market by 4.8X with an average return of 185% compared to 39% for the S&P500.

Rule Breakers Picks (Q4 2018)Rate of ReturnReturn on $500 Investment
Bilibili (BILI)541.8%$2709
Zendesk (ZEN)121.8%$609
Guardant Health (GH)206.6%$1033
Upwork (UPWK)111.3%$557
Upwork (UPWK)95.8%$479
Electronic Arts (EA)35.2%$176

64% of Rule Breakers Picks Have +100% Returns

Over the last 17 years 83% of Rule Breakers picks have produced positive returns with 64% up +100% and 40% up over +250%.

Rule Breakers Recommendation PeriodPicks with Positive Returns+100% Returns+250% Returns
2004 to Present83.33%63.51%39.64%
201991.67%54.17%12.50%
201875.00%50.00%16.67%
201790.48%61.90%38.10%
201690.91%68.18%27.27%

Click Here to Try Rule Breakers (May 15, 2021)

Rule Breakers Investment Criteria

Stock picks for Rule Breakers are heavily focused on companies with the following characteristics.

  1. Market leader or first to enter an emerging industry.
  2. Durable advantage from momentum, patents, leadership or lacking competitors.
  3. Strong historical price appreciation.
  4. Strong management team with “smart backing”.
  5. Brand with strong consumer appeal.
  6. Companies believed to be overvalued by the mainstream.

Rule Breakers What You Get:

Best Buys Now: Best investment opportunities from all the picks.

Starter Stocks: Foundational stocks for new investors to build out a strong portfolio.

Investor Community: Gain access to a large community of investors, sharing stock picks and investment strategies.

Premium Content: Industry reports and articles covering the domains of Rule Breaker’s picks.

Price of Rule Breakers: $99/year (for new members) which is 67% off the regular price of $299/year and comes with a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee.

Click Here to See the Latest Rule Breaker Picks (May 15, 2021)

Attention: Don’t miss David Gardners next Rule Breakers picks on May 13th and 27th. New members can get the service for $99/year which is 67% off the regular price. Try Rule Breakers Risk Free for 30 days.


Motley Fool Stock Advisor Overview:

Stock Advisor is led by co-founders David and Tom Gardner and just like Rule Breakers they release two stock recommendations per month.

Stock Advisor is a great option for those building a new portfolio. In addition to the two new stock picks each month you’ll also get 10 starter stock which are the best long term investments from past recommendations. Additionally two times per month you’ll get 5 stocks which are the best timely buys right now.

The Stock Advisor team continually tracks the performance and developments of all past recommendations and these timely buys are based on the past picks that present the best buying opportunity right now.

A big difference between Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers is that both David and Tom each provide a stock recommendation based on their investing criteria, while Rule Breakers only features picks from David Gardner.

As part of Stock Advisor David’s picks focus on companies with “undeniable, long-term trends” and “unquantifiable greatness” ideally wanting to get in early and adding to his positions as the growth continues.

Tom’s picks focus on great companies in “beaten-down” but still relevant industries ideally with strong management ownership.

Overall Performance of the Stock Picks: Average pick’s up 504% compared to 95% for S&P500.

Price of Stock Advisor: $99/year (for new members) which is 50% off the regular price of $199/year and comes with a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee.

Click Here to See the Latest Stock Advisor Picks (May 15, 2021)

ATTENTION: Don’t miss the next picks from David Gardner on May 20th. New members can get full access to the service for $99/year. Try Stock Advisor risk free for 30 days.


»RELATED: Best Stocks to Invest in for the Long-Term

Motley Fool Stock Advisor vs Rule Breakers

ComparisonStock AdvisorRule Breakers
Performance578% vs 129% S&P336% vs 111% S&P
FocusMix of Small to Large Cap High Growth StocksDisruptive Growth Stocks
AnalystsDavid & Tom GardnerDavid Gardner
Investment Period3-5+ Years3-5+ Years
30 Day RefundYesYes
Price$199 $99 / Year (for new members)$299 $99 / Year (for new members)

The Bottom Line:

Overall all both services have long track records of beating the market making it easy to recommend either service. Stock Advisor has a more open ended investing approach and may appeal to more investors while Rule Breakers focus is on disruptive growth companies that tend to focus largely in the tech space.

Both come with a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee so why not give both a try.

Click Here to Try Stock Advisor Risk Free for 30 Days (May 15, 2021)