Advertiser DisclosureWe strive for editorial intergrity. We receive compensation from some of the links, products and or services mentioned in this post. Click to read more

Motley Rule Breakers Review vs Stock Advisor – Which Investing Service is Best?

- TraderHQ Staff

Motley Fool Subscriptions

The Motley Fool offers two very popular stock picking services; Rule Breakers and Stock Advisor. Both have out-performed the market by a wide margin and both focus on stocks with long-term growth in mind. Both are very complimentary so for those interested in both services the best deal is their bundle offer.

Let’s jump right into the comparison of the two investing services so you can decide which or both is right for you.

Motley Fool Rule Breakers

Rule Breakers is run by David Gardner and has been providing monthly stock recommendations since 2004, let’s take a closer look at some of the services best picks, recent picks and to-date performance.

A $500 investment in these 5 Rule Breakers picks is worth $244,576 today.

Rule Breakers Stock Picks (2004 to 2022)ReturnAnnualized Return
EV Company14,625%1,360%
Intl. e-Commerce Company6,311%465%
Intuitive Surgical (ISRG)3,966%227%
NetEase (NTES)3,760%212%
Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG)2,705%173%

Click Here to See the Latest Rule Breakers Picks (Sep 22nd, 2022)

Recent Performance

We know that Rule Breakers has had some huge all-time picks, but how have their more recent picks performed? Let’s take a closer look and find out.

Top Rule Breakers Picks From 2016 to 2022

These are the best stock picks from the Rule Breakers service from 2016 to 2022. The service releases two new stock picks per month.

Rule Breakers Stock Picks (2016 to 2022)ReturnAnnualized Return
Ad Tech Company1,695%308%
e-Commerce Company1,372%211%
Boutique e-Commerce Company692%120%
Atlassian (TEAM)684%116%
Medical Company653%196%

Q4 2019 – Rule Breakers Stock Picks

The Q4 2019 Rule Breakers picks have beat the market by 4.2X with an average return of 227% compared to 55% for the S&P 500.

Rule Breakers Stock Picks from Q4 2019ReturnAnnualized Return
Cloud Data Company188%66%
Boutique e-Commerce Company148%52%
Diabetes Equip Company38%14%
Novocure (NVCR)9%3%
Pet Company-31%-11%

Latest Rule Breakers Picks

The latest Rule Breakers pick was released on September 15th.

Latest Rule Breakers Stock Picks 2022Revenue Cagr (3Y)Sector
Stock Advisor Pick (2022-09-15)28.08%United States
Stock Advisor Pick (2022-08-25)39.01%United States
Stock Advisor Pick (2022-08-11)57.72%United States
Stock Advisor Pick (2022-07-28)--

Next Rule Breakers Pick

The next Rule Breakers pick will be released on September 29th.

Rule Breakers Release ScheduleRelease Date
New Stock PickSep 15, 2022
5 Best Buys NowSep 22, 2022
New Stock PickSep 29, 2022
5 Best Buys NowOct 6, 2022

Click Here to See the Latest Rule Breakers Picks (Sep 22nd, 2022)

How Does Rule Breakers Work?

Rule Breakers is built on the conviction that investing early in great high-growth companies for the long-term will produce the highest returns. The teams mission is to find tomorrows great growth stocks before Wall Street does. Some of the best examples include Tesla, MercadoLibre and Intuitive Surgical.

In order to have the best success in growth stock investing Rule Breakers has developed an investing criteria which helps identify the very best growth investments with the highest chance of long-term sustainable growth.

Not every company will encompass all six of the investment criteria, however those that do have a record of extraordinary growth over a long period of time.

Rule Breakers Investment Criteria

  1. First to market or “best in class” in an emerging industry.
  2. Sustainable advantage from momentum, patents, leadership or lacking competitors.
  3. Strong historical price appreciation.
  4. Strong management team with “smart backing”.
  5. Brand with strong consumer appeal.
  6. Companies believed to be overvalued by the mainstream.

The world is always changing and learning how to capitalize on powerful growth trends can lead to great investment opportunities. Investment trends like…

  • Streaming media
  • The digital payment revolution
  • Cloud computing
  • Remote work
  • Online advertising
  • e-commerce
  • Tele-medicine

What You Get with Rule Breakers

What you get with Rule Breakers is much more than just monthly stock picks. Investing mistakes can be extremely painful and Rule Breakers provides an incredible education from phenomenal investors with time-tested investment knowledge which is truly an invaluable benefit of being a member.

Here are some of the most important things you get with a Rule Breakers subscription.

New Stock Picks: Two new stock picks are released per month. Each pick comes with a buy recommendation report.

10 Starter Stocks: “Starter Stocks” are provided to all members and meant to provide a foundation to newer portfolios with a risk and reward balance.

Best Buys Now: Bi-weekly the team releases a list of 5 “Best Buys Now” stocks which are the current highest conviction picks from the Rule Breakers portfolio.

Scorecard: Every stock pick since 2004 is tracked on the Rule Breakers scorecard covering returns, recommendation date, link to buy report, return to date, return vs benchmark and more.

Access to Motley Fool Live!: 8 hours daily live streaming programs offering deep dives on stock picks, CEO interviews, investing mindsets, Q&A and more.

Premium Content: Industry reports and articles covering the domains of Rule Breaker’s picks including….

  • 5G Revolution
  • Autonomous driving
  • Next Gen Entertainment
  • The Next Amazon
  • The future of streaming
  • iPhone Supercycle
  • Tools: Asset allocation tool helping structure a portfolio according to risk tolerance and time horizon.

    Investor Community: Gain access to a large community of investors, sharing stock picks and investment strategies.

    Price of Rule Breakers: $99/year (for new members) which is 67% off the regular price of $299/year and comes with a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee.

Click Here to See the Latest Rule Breakers Picks (Sep 22nd, 2022)


Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Motley Fool Stock Advisor is led by co-founders David and Tom Gardner and just like Rule Breakers they release two stock recommendations per month.

Stock Advisor is a great option for those building a new portfolio. In addition to the two new stock picks each month you’ll also get 10 starter stock which are the best long term investments from past recommendations. Additionally two times per month you’ll get 5 stocks which are the best timely buys right now.

The Stock Advisor team continually tracks the performance and developments of all past recommendations and these timely buys are based on the past picks that present the best buying opportunity right now.

A big difference between Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers is that both David and Tom each provide a stock recommendation based on their investing criteria, while Rule Breakers only features picks from David Gardner.

As part of Stock Advisor David’s picks focus on companies with “undeniable, long-term trends” and “unquantifiable greatness” ideally wanting to get in early and adding to his positions as the growth continues.

Tom’s picks focus on great companies in “beaten-down” but still relevant industries ideally with strong management ownership.

Overall Performance of the Stock Picks: Average pick’s up 504% compared to 95% for S&P500.

Price of Stock Advisor: $99/year (for new members) which is 50% off the regular price of $199/year and comes with a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee.

Click here to See the Latest Stock Advisor Picks (Sep 22nd, 2022)

Stock Advisor vs Rule Breakers – Final Thoughts

Overall both services have long track records of beating the market and both are $99/year for new members making it easy to recommend either service as they provide great value.

Motley Fool Stock Advisor has a more open ended investing approach and may appeal to more investors while Rule Breakers focus is strictly on disruptive growth companies that tend to focus largely in the tech space and come with greater volatility in the short-term.

Both services work in a very complimentary way and will give you greater exposure to high quality, growth stock picks and thus if you can afford we recommend trying both. Both come with a 30-day money back guarantee so you don’t have much to lose.

If you only want to try one, we recommend starting with Stock Advisor first and then add on Rule Breakers at a later point after you have started building out a portfolio.

Bundle Offer: Stock Advisor + Rule Breakers + Everlasting Stocks. 1 Year for $299

Rule Breakers FAQ

How much does Rule Breakers cost?

Rule Breakers is offering one year access for $99 (for new members), which is $200 off from their regular price. Rule Breakers is also available inside of a special bundle discount which includes Stock Advisor and Rule Breakers together for just $199/year for new members, which is $300 off the regular price of $499/year.

What type of stocks does Rule Breakers recommend?

Rule Breakers focuses on high growth companies that are often first to market or disruptive with their product, service or strategies. The core Rule Breakers belief is that investing early in these type of Rule Breakers high-growth companies for the long-term will produce the best returns.

How do you use Rule Breakers?

Motley Fool Rule Breakers is a source high growth stock recommendations that you can purchase with your own brokerage account. The service advocates for investing in great companies and holding them for the long term 3-5+ years with a portfolio size of at least 15 stocks.

The service provides…

1. Two new stock recommendations per month. 2. Monthly “Best Buy” stocks which are the teams highest conviction stocks from past recommendations. 3. 10 “Starter Stocks” which are their best long-term stock ideas which make a great foundation for new portfolios.

The service helps provide a great framework for new and seasoned investors to build winning portfolios. They provide and endless supply of helpful resources aimed at helping people with all aspects of investing including mindset and psychology, strategy and of course great stock recommendations. Probably the most understated value of any Motley Fool service is the community of like minded investors that you instantly become a part of.

Does Rule Breakers Give Guidance When to Sell?

Rule Breakers provides both buy and sell guidance, however it should be understood that the Rule Breakers investment philosophy is one of longer term investing and not trading. Their sell guidance is given when the investing thesis has changed for a given company and thus they give guidance and reasonings for why their long-term outlook for the company has changed and why they recommend to sell or hold.

Does Rule Breakers come with a Free Trial?

Motley Fool Rule Breakers comes with a 30-day money back guaranteed. This means that customers can try out the entire service and access all the recommendations, resources and tool before committing to a yearly subscription which is $99 for new members.

What are Rule Breakers “Starter Stocks”?

Rule Breakers gives subscribers 10 starter stocks which the team believes to be the best long-term, high growth opportunities from the Rule Breakers portfolio.

Rule Breakers advises investors buy at least 15 stocks and the starter stocks are meant to help new investors build out a strong portfolio with both growth and stability in mind.

Click Here to See the Latest Rule Breakers Picks (Sep 22nd, 2022)

Quotes of the Day:

  • “The idea that a bell rings to signal when to get into or out of the stock market is simply not credible. After nearly fifty years in this business, I don’t know anybody who has done it successfully and consistently. I don’t even know anybody who knows anybody who has.” - Jack Bogle
  • "One of the funny things about the stock market is that every time one person buys, another sells, and both think they are astute". – William Feather
  • "I don’t think there is any other quality so essential to success of any kind as the quality of perseverance. It overcomes almost everything, even nature". - John D. Rockefeller
  • "We don’t have to be smarter than the rest, we have to be more disciplined than the rest". – Warren Buffett
  • "We don't prognosticate macroeconomic factors, we're looking at our companies from a bottom-up perspective on their long-run prospects of returning." – Mellody Hobson
  • “The best way to measure your investing success is not by whether you’re beating the market but by whether you’ve put in place a financial plan and a behavioral discipline that are likely to get you where you want to go.” - Benjamin Graham
  • "It's not how much money you make, but how much money you keep, how hard it works for you, and how many generations you keep it for." – Robert Kiyosaki